Tisha B’av Schedule for Congregation Adath Israel

Friday July 20th, 2018

Erev Shabbos

6:20 pm                Mincha (Plag: 6:52) (Repeat Shema after 9:12)

8:05 pm                Candle Lighting (Not Before 6:52)

8:15 pm                Mincha

Shabbos July 21, 2018

7:00 am                Hashkama Minyan (Silverstein Room) followed by Sefer Hachinuch & Parshanut Shiurim

8:30 am                Minyan Sefardim

8:35 am                Mishna Yomis (Rav Schwartz)

8:45 am                Shachris (Main Shul) – Kiddush follows Services (SZKS: 9:23)

                                                         Daf Yomi follows davening in Shul (Rav Schwartz)

1:03 pm                           Chatzos

5:00 pm            Eicha Rabba (Rav Schwartz)

5:30 pm                Mincha (Ashkenaz & Sefardi)

8:22 pm                Fast Begins/SHABBOS DOES NOT END UNTIL 9:12 pm

9:12 pm                Shabbos ends: Say Baruch HaMavdil, Borai Me’orai Ha’eish (on Havdala candle) and change shoes

9:30 pm                Maariv

9:45 pm                Eicha/Kinnos with commentary and explanation (Rav Schwartz)

(A special phone hookup will be available for those who wish to call in.  Dial-in Number )

(The Mikvah is not opened tonight)

 Sunday July 22, 2018

Tisha B’Av-observed

6:30 am                Shachris (Ashkenaz) & Kinnos with commentary <Rav Schwartz>

8:00 am                Minyan Sefardim Shachris with Kinnos <Rav Schwartz>

9:00 am                Shachris (Ashkenaz) & Kinnos with commentary (SZKS: 9:23)

9:40 am                         Kinnos with explanations (A special phone hookup will be available for those who wish to call in.  Dial-in Number:

10-1                  Women’s Kinnos Program at JEC Reibel Beis HaMedrash

12:45 pm             Geleibter Foundation Video (“V’Nikdashtee”) in Youth Wing (no charge)

1:03 pm                Chatzos (can sit on chairs)

1:40 pm                Mincha (Ashkenaz) – Please remember Tallis & Tefillin

2 pm                    REBUILDING THE MIKDASH MIAT – Join us in the Chessed of Restructuring the Shul (Help wth the Chessed of reshelving and clearing areas of our Shul)

2:15 pm                Chofetz Chaim YOUTH program & video in youth wing (Cost: $5.00 per child; max $15.00 per family)

2:30 pm                Chofetz Chaim Heritage Videos for adults @ JEC (There is a charge for this event)

4:30-6:30                      Rabbi Carlebach’s Tisha B’Av Learning Program for Boys Entering Grades 5 and up @ JEC Location: TBA

6:55 pm                Shiur: “Profiles in Exile - The Life and Times of Don Isaac Abarbanel ” (Rav Schwartz)

7:55 pm                Mincha (Ashkenaz and Minyan Sefaradim) – Please remember Tallis & Tefillin

8:30 pm                Maariv Followed by Kiddush Levana and Mishna Yomis

9:04 pm                Fast ends (do not forget to recite Havdala)

(Mikvah will be opened for women from 10-11:15 )

When Tisha b’Av falls on Shabbos…

Elsewhere, we have written extensively on the frequently asked questions concerning the Three weeks. However, given the unique status of Tisha B’av when it falls out on Shabbos, we thought it would be helpful to establish a context of practices for the entire weekend[1].


1.  On Friday afternoon close to the onset of Shabbos, it is permitted to feed children - who normally eat at that time - the regular meaty Shabbos foods[2]. A woman who needs to taste the Shabbos foods while cooking may do so on Friday afternoon after midday[3]. On Shabbos there is no restriction against eating meat or drinking wine even if one began Shabbos early - any time after plag ha-Minchah.

2.  A woman may go to the Mikvah as normally scheduled[4] and be with her husband afterward[5]. For all other Ashkenazim, it is customary to observe the prohibitions of Tashmish Hamitta as it IS the day of Tisha B’Av. Sefardim do not have the practice of separating on the Shabbos[6].


1.  One is permitted to serve meat and drink wine at all meals throughout the Shabbos,[7] including Seudah Shlishit. One may not limit himself on this Shabbos simply because it is Tisha b’Av Shabbos.[8] Even one who does not normally sing Zemiros, can sing Zemiros on this Shabbos as long as it is a “Shir Shel Shabbos (A song of Shabbos).[9]

2.  There is a major debate as to whether one should have a large meal with guests at the Shabbos meals on this Shabbos.[10]

3.  One may wash oneself and wear leather shoes throughout the Shabbos.[11] Therefore, when washing for Hamotzee, one should wash one’s hands until the end of the wrist as usual.

4   .On Shabbos afternoon, one should not go for walks or engage in other social activities[12]

5.  There is a debate among the Poskim as to whether one may proceed with his regular Torah study schedule on Shabbos.[13] Others argue that one may learn what s/he wishes until mid-day (1:03 pm)[14]. Others feel that since the day is Shabbos, to limit one’s ability to study that which s/he wishes would constitute public Aveilus which we do not engage in on Shabbos. [15]

6   .Ashkenazim do not recite Pirkei Avos on Shabbos afternoon.[16]

7 .One is permitted to finish reading the sedra – 2 Mikra and Echad Targum[17] even in the afternoon.

8.  One may eat meat even for Seudah Shlishit. One may bentch with a Mezuman as well.[18]Care should be taken to insure that one completes Seudah shlishit and all eating and drinking before SUNSET (Elizabeth/Hillside 8:22 pm) even though Shabbos does not end until Tzeis HaKochavim (9:12 pm Elizabeth/Hillside time). If one bentsched early and wanted to drink water but did not make a condition permitting him to do so, s/he may still drink water until sunset.[19]

9. One may clean up the leftover food from Seudah Shlishit and put it in the fridge. Cleaning the table would present a problem of Hachana (preparation from Shabbos to a weekday) if done for no reason while it is still Shabbos.

10. One may not make any preparations on Shabbos for Tisha B’av. This includes carrying shoes or Kinnos to Shul. One may not prepare the Shul for Tisha B’Av on Shabbos including flipping the benches down.[20]

Tisha B’Av of a Nidche

1.  At the end of Shabbos (Elizabeth/Hillside 9:12 pm) one should recite Baruch HaMavdil bein Kodesh l’Chol and remove ones leather shoes. If one can, one should also recite the Beracha of Borai Meorai Haeish in case someone at home will not be traveling to Shul to hear it there.[21]

2.  Havdala is not recited until AFTER the fast. If one must break his/her fast, Havdala should be recited on Chamar Medina and the Berachos of SheHakol and HaMavdil should be said.[22]

3.  The rules of a Choleh are different than in other years. If a person meets these requirements, s/he should seek guidance from a Rav.

Motzai Tisha B’Av

1.  Havdala is recited after the fast. It is merely the Beracha on the wine and the Beracha of HaMavdil. The Berachos over Besamim and Ner are not recited.[23]

2.  Whereas in most years, we continue with all mourning practices until midday after the fast, this year that is unnecessary as it is already the 11th of Av after nightfall. Accordingly, one may listen to music, do laundry, shower etc. immediately after the fast. However, one should not eat meat or drink wine (except for Havdala) until the next morning.[24]

[1] This review reflects a collaborative effort of Rav E.M. Teitz and Rav Schwartz. The positions expressed herein have met with their approval.

[2] Igros Moshe O.C. 4:21-4.

[3] Mekor Chayim 551:9.

[4] See Yoreh Deah 194

[5] Mishna Berurah 554:40 in the name of the Shelah; See Shaar Hatziyun 554:46 about one who was away all week and see Nitei Gavriel, Bein HaMetzarim vol. II 93:3-4 about husbands who go up to the country as to whether they are HaBa Min HaDerech

[6] See Chazon Ovadiah on the 4 fasts, p. 304

[7] O.C. 552:10

[8] Mishna Berurah 552:23; Shmiras Shabbos K’Hilchasa II: 56:14.

[9] Iggros Moshe O.C. IV:112.

[10] See Mogen Avrohom 552:14 and Aruch Hashulchan 552:12 who are opposed to having guests as they are of the opinion that one should eat Seudas Shlomo haMelech but alone with his family. Mishna Berurah 552:23 disagrees and feels that limiting the meal would be a public declaration of mourning which is not permitted on Shabbos. See also Shmiras Shabbos K’Hilchasa II:56:14.

[11] 554:19.

[12] Birkei Yosef O.C. 553:5 and Shaarei Teshuva 553:5. See also Rema to 553:2.

[13] See Mogen Avrohom 553:7 who forbids Torah study except in the passages permitted to be studied on Tisha B’Av itself. See also Shut Chasam Sofer, O.C. 346 who would allow Iyun into those areas that one may study on Tisha B’av even according to this strict view.

[14] See Rema, O.C. 553:2. This position seems to be most pronounced among the Achronim (See summary in Nitei Gavriel, Bein HaMetzarim II: 92:2

[15] See Taz to Orach Chaim 553:2. See also Gra’s comments there that Torah study limitations constitute an untenable chumra. Mishna Berurah (553:10) also encourages leniency here.

[16] See Rema 553:2. It should be noted that Rav Ovadiah Yosef (Chazon Ovadiah, 4 Taaniyos p. 310) does not understand the basis for this elimination and chalks it up to the fact that the learning can be made up afterward. However, participating in an established regular Seder which by definition cannot be “made up” should not be discarded on this Shabbos (Shut Divrei Yatziv O.C. II: 241). I have heard that based on these arguments coupled with the argument of Bittul Torah D'Rabim, Rav Shmuel Kamenetzsky has allowed a regular Daf Yomi shiur to meet at its regular time on Shabbos afternoon – in order not to violate the established practice.

[17] Mogen Avraham 554:7; Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 125:4.

[18] Mishna Berurah 552:23

[19] Shaar Hatziyun 553:7

[20] Nittei Gavriel Bein Hametzarim II: 93:9.

[21] Orach Chaim 556:1. See Shut Shevet HaLevi Vii: 77 if one should recite the Beracha at home if everyone will be in Shul to hear it there.

[22] See Shaarei Teshuva 556:1 and Shut Divrei Yatziv 242& 243 who recommends Chamar Medina over wine. This was also purportedly the position of Rav Moshe Feinstein.

[23] See O.C. 256:1.

[24] See Rema 558:1 and Mishna Berurah 558:4.